It helps to be literal here: high-performance liquid chromatography is a separation technique, not an identification technique, and it answers the question "how much of the detected signal is a single species" not "which species is it."
System suitability checks on replicate injections of a known standard establish whether the method was in control — if the peak area varies by more than two per cent between replicates, something is wrong.
Temperature affects both the viscosity of the mobile phase and the dynamics of molecular interactions, and a method developed at 25 degrees and run at 40 degrees will not behave identically.
The resolving power of a separation is quantified by the resolution parameter R, defined from the heights and widths of adjacent peaks, and pharmacopoeial methods typically demand R greater than 1.5 for a method to be considered validated.
If two labs give different numbers, the method difference is the first hypothesis, not lab quality.
edited 21 Jul 2025 by s_kalniete — added the citation requested in comments
6This should probably be in the site help pages rather than buried in an answer. – Dr_Idris_Coulibaly 2 months ago 5Good answer, but the confidence interval in the cited trial is wider than implied. – Dr_Ilse_Vandenberg 14 days ago add a comment