Stated carefully, reporting threshold is convention and not chemistry, which is why two certificates with different thresholds disagree by a tenth of a point or more.
Column pore size affects mass transfer — a 100 Angstrom packing on a 5 kDa peptide restricts diffusion, broadening the peak and potentially hiding small impurities in the shoulders.
Sample solvent strength affects peak shape — if you inject in strong solvent on a gradient starting in weak solvent, the solvent peak can distort your main peak or create a false shoulder.
Published side-by-side method comparisons show that a two-point difference in purity on the same vial is easily explained by method choice alone.
I would be careful about over-reading a single measurement — treat it as a data point, not as ground truth.
Compare purity within a single laboratory on the same method, never across laboratories.