High-performance liquid chromatography is a separation technique, not an identification technique, and it answers the question "how much of the detected signal is a single species" not "which species is it."
Formic acid is the compromise when you need the mass spectrometer on the same run, but the peak shape penalty is real and easily a tenth of a per cent on purity.
Put another way, wider-pore phases — 300 Angstrom rather than 100 Angstrom — have faster mass transfer and narrower peaks for peptides above three kilodaltons, which is almost every peptide you will see.
The limitation is that co-elution is invisible — if two species happen to have the same retention time, they will report as a single peak at their combined area.
The practical summary: specify the method, run the same method on every sample you compare, and use orthogonal techniques to confirm the result.
6Related: the same reasoning applies to the counter-ion question. – tandem_gradient 23 days ago add a comment