The short version: same compound, same laboratory, same method, ideally same week — otherwise you are comparing laboratories rather than suppliers.
To compare properly: order the same compound at the same nominal strength from each supplier, submit all samples to the same laboratory in the same submission if possible, and ask for the same test set on each.
Publish the method with the result. A comparison without the laboratory named and the submission dates given is not reproducible by anyone.
Inter-laboratory spread on identical peptide material is routinely half a per cent to a per cent by RP-HPLC, which is the noise floor for any cross-laboratory comparison.
Use a fixed documentation checklist rather than an impression.
edited 21 Dec 2025 by deamidation_watch — clarified the distinction between purity and content