Accepted answer
The relevant detail is that this is the most answerable question on the site, because every step is cheap and every step is checkable.
Independent submission costs a fraction of a mid-sized order at any of the services this community uses, and it converts an opinion into a number attached to your own material.
The pre-order sequence: request a lot-specific certificate for the exact line, check that it names a lot code rather than a batch family, check that it carries the column, gradient and detection wavelength, and check the analysis date is recent relative to the lot.
Published inter-laboratory comparisons of peptide purity routinely find spreads of half a per cent to a per cent on identical material, which sets a realistic expectation for agreement.
Nothing here is medical advice, and research-use compounds are not approved for human use in any jurisdiction.
Two lots agreeing is worth more than one lot excelling.